About GamePeople

Puddle XBLA Review

24/02/2012 Artistic Novel Gamer Review
Created by
Game Reviews
Home | Family Video Game Guides | Artistic | The Novel Gamer Column

Subscribe to the Novel Gamer column:
RSS or Newsletter.

Why not try our Blog, Radio or TV shows. Click for samples...

Puddle XBLA





Support Chris, click to buy via us...

Puddle XBLA initially appears familiar, but at the same time feel completely fresh. It's part racing game, part platformer and is really, really hard.

The knock at the door barely caused Abe Weinmann to look up from his desk. It took a lot to get the producer's attention and simply coming into his office wasn't enough to do it. If an actor wanted to be in one of Weinmann's pictures, he had to make an impression.

What did grab his attention was a globby, bubbling noise coming from the floor. He peered over the edge of the desk to see what it was and it seemed to be that his office had been entered by a small puddle of liquid. It seemed to be looking at him, quizzically.

Weinmann didn't know what to make of this new performer. Sure, he was something that audiences hadn't seen before and Abe liked to keep things fresh. On the flip side, this blob didn't have any way of making an emotive expression on his face. Still, the producer thought, that still puts him in the running for another Matrix sequel.

"Alright," Abe responded, with grudging respect, "you're different. Show me something."

Puddle comes across as equal parts escapist fantasy and geekdom-fuelled science lecture. The basic premise is simple enough: rotate the side-scrolling world left and right to allow a fluid to travel through a maze using a mixture of gravity, momentum and mass to leap ramps, activate switches and avoid traps.

Featureless liquid wouldn't be most writers' choice for a central character in a drama, but it's the cleverness of the scenario which turns what may otherwise have been a dry physics puzzler into a daring escape adventure. Whether trapped in a heater, rocking back and forth to raise the pressure and create an escape route or creeping along a ledge slowly and carefully to avoid a nitroglycerin-fuelled explosion, there is a natural drama created which I found gave me a thrilling sense of impetus for my journey and a rewarding feeling at each goal.

There is a natural drama created which I found gave me a thrilling sense of impetus.

You'll need a good mix of approaches in Puddle to win through. At times it feels like a racing game, travelling as quickly as possible around bends and over jumps to reach the finish line with as much remaining fluid as possible. Other times the game will test the accuracy of your control, challenging you to jump a bubble of flammable liquid between two red hot lasers.

The plot - sort of - tells the story of a cupful of water gradually making an initial escape before heading into different environments and changing its own form along the way. Each different state brings advantages or disadvantages, such as the weed killer state with removes plant-growth obstacles, or the petrol state which is easily flammable and must be cooled frequently to dowse flames.

It's a clever way of introducing different places in which fluid mechanics are significant, such as a drainage system, a rocket motor or even the human body. More than that, it's extremely clever writing, because it allows the game to deliver different environments for each level without falling into the usual grass/ice/fire world cliches of most platformers.

The art style isn't always very consistent between environments. I actually can't decide whether this is criticism or praise. For example the lab levels take a very photo-realistic view of the liquid and environments, but the following outdoor level appears to be slightly more cel-shaded and cartoony. Later levels become even more stylised. On the one hand the changing style rankles a little, particularly if a newly-introduced style is less to your taste. Conversely, it seems that choosing an art style which is sympathetic to the subject matter of the level seems highly appropriate and probably something which more games should consider.

I can definitely recommend Puddle as a treat for the senses.

That said, regardless of which style Puddle is aiming for at any given moment it is almost always very beautiful. Despite the scientific inspiration, the tubes, switches and pipes are rendered with a painterly eye and a love of colour and contrast. If you're starting to tire of the similar tones in which many modern games are drawn then I can definitely recommend Puddle as a treat for the senses.

Be warned that Puddle can be very tough and occasionally frustrating. The stringent attention to fluid dynamics means that your trail of liquid will often break up throughout the route. The game makes a good effort at managing the camera for you, but at times it's hard to figure out which particles are still considered part of the player and which have become acceptable loss. The game allows for a small number of level skips, in recognition that many players will come really unstuck in a few levels. But these are extremely limited and furthermore goad the player by labelling these "whines".

Puddle is a much more original and fresh title than its initial premise suggests. I have seen liquid-pouring puzzle games before, but never one which takes the concept and finds as many ways to wring gameplay possibilities out of the characteristics of different substances. Additionally, the very last thing I expected to find was a escape drama of such gripping tension and scope. Puddle is a treat indeed!

Written by Chris Jarvis

You can support Chris by buying Puddle

Subscribe to this column:
RSS | Newsletter

Share this review:

Chris Jarvis writes the Novel Gamer column.

"I write stories to say what I think about games, for me it's the only way I can really communicate what I feel about them. Do you ever have a response to something that's hard to put into words? I find that sometimes I have something to express that can't be communicated by trying to explain how I feel, directly."

© GamePeople 2006-13 | Contact | Huh?

Grown up gaming?

Family Video Game Age Ratings | Home | About | Radio shows | Columnists | Competitions | Contact

RSS | Email | Twitter | Facebook

With so many different perspectives it can be hard to know where to start - a little like walking into a crowded pub. Sorry about that.

But so far we've not found a way to streamline our review output - there's basically too much of it. So, rather than dilute things for newcomers we have decided to live with the hubbub while helping new readers find the columnists they will enjoy.

What sort of gamer are you?

Our columnists each focus on a particular perspective and fall into one of the following types of gamers: