Skylanders Giants announced, and we are in New York to get a first hand look at the game and Skylanders Giant figures.
Previously on FGTV...
Pilot Episode: Pestridge Family Start Gaming
Episode 1.1: Pestridge Family Try Kinect
Episode 1.2: Pestridge Family Kinect Favs
Episode 1.3: Pestridge Family Tries PS3
Episode 1.4: Skylanders visit in San Francisco
Episode 1.5: Emmens Dad Kids Starts Gaming
Episode 1.6: Pestridge Mum Talks Kinect
Episode 1.7: Pestridge Super Young Gamers
Episode 1.8: Pestridge Dad uDraw and 3DS
Episode 1.9: Pestridge Mum tries Mario 3DS
Episode 1.10: Pestridge Mum Skylanders
Episode 1.11: Emmens Family Lego Games
Episode 1.12: Your Shape Fitness Part 1
Episode 1.13: Your Shape Fitness Part 2
Episode 1.14: Pestridge Mum Disneyland
Episode 1.15: Emmens Try Forza 4
Episode 1.16: Emmens iPad Gaming
Episode 1.17: Emmens Try 3DS and Mario
Episode 1.18: Guided Tour of the DS
Episode 1.19: Mum's Gaming Reality check
Episode 1.20: Emmens Plays Kinectimals
Episode 1.21: Emmens Try Skylanders
Episode 1.22: Season One Outtakes
Episode 1.23: Emmens try AppMates
Episode 1.24: Hilsons try PS Vita
Episode 1.25: Skylanders Giants
Episode 1.26: Skylanders Giants Devs
Episode 1.27: Kinect Rush Devs
Episode 1.28: Grand Slam Tennis 2
Episode 1.29: Skylanders Giants CEO
Episode 1.30: Hilsons try Runescape
Episode 1.31: Mum talks WiiU and Layton
Episode 1.32: Kinect Rush Gameplay
Episode 1.33: Kinect Star Wars
Episode 1.34: Right to Play Kinect
Enjoyed this? Why not try our radio shows.
Skylanders Giants was revealed today as the next step for the franchise at an event in New York that echoed Skylanders: Spyro’s Adventure original announcement at last year’s Toy Fair. Since that announcement last year the game has gone from strength to strength — something seen in the voracious popularity of the toy figures ($7.99 Amazon) that grant access to the different video game characters selling out.
Skylanders has come under criticism in some quarters for including promotional videos in the game-play to publicize the different toy figures you could buy. Some also criticized the game for only making characters and worlds available if players had purchased extra figures. That said, you could complete the game with the three that came with the Starter Pack ($49.99 Amazon), something that would take most players a good 20 hours.
Skylanders Giants is a substantial update to what is becoming a fast-growing franchise for Activision. While some thought this might simply be more figures with some added DLC, it is in fact an out-and-out sequel. Gameplay is largely similar and offers a new shared-screen multiplayer story but the real interest is in the way Skylanders Giants, no doubt controversially for some, extends the range of toys that accompany the experience:
The original set of figures and any upgrades/experience/hats you have earned are supported by the new game but new figures can’t be played with the original adventure. Interestingly, the figures I got my hands on at the event all had orange (rather than green) base plates. This may well reflect the need to distinguish between original and new sets of Skylanders figures at retail. This color coding system will help ensure players buy figures appropriate for their version of the game.
The new game offers considerable value for those who have invested in a collection of Skylanders already. Not only will it offer a new main adventure but each character’s challenge modes will be updated with new levels. The gameplay mechanics are largely the same as the original, although the introduction of the Giant characters creates new interactive scenarios. Some routes through the game will need a Giant Skylander to access.
While it sounds like you will be able to finish the game with any characters you own, Skylanders Giants undoubtedly introduces a few new reasons to extend your collection — not least with the full update of those original Skylanders figures. It will be interesting to see if Skylanders Giants is sold on its own, or whether you will have to buy it in Starter Pack form with one of the Giants figures. I suspect that this would be the case otherwise many of the new game’s features will not be accessible.
Playing the game, I was impressed at how integrated the Giants were to the action. There was also something very engaging about matching the outsized Giant Tree Smash figure with the diminutive Stealth Elf. Although the Giant Skylander was much stronger and inflicted more damage there were more than a few occasions when Stealth Elf’s agility gave her the advantage.
Seeing the Giant Skylander light up as it gets near to the Portal is also a very nice touch (and on my children’s wish list). It adds to the already strong sense of connection between the real world toy figure and the video game character. I know my kids will also want a method of lighting them up when away from the game though which was not mentioned at the presentation. Being able to hide a glowing Giant Skylander under your duvet at bedtime would be worth the price of entry alone for my eldest son. I’m sure it will also signal various nighttime versions of the games they play with the toys, again making use of their ability to light up.
Overall it really is more of the same for Skylanders, but this is no bad thing. There is the same tension between the marketing and creativity the game has to offer. Continuing to get this balance right will be increasingly difficult as the range of figures grows though — particularly if the new figures signal a cessation of the originals, which will further inflate their already ludicrous second hand value.
Either way, provided they can solve their toy distribution issues (so players can easily purchase figures for their RRP) the level of innovation in the Light, Giant and New Skylanders figures should be enough to allay any short term frustrations that parents may have with the game.
It won’t be until we have more details, and full hands-on time with Skylanders Giants, that we will be able to tell just how good the next Skylanders chapter is. My children have developed quite a bond to their collection of Skylanders toys, who accompany us pretty much everywhere from shopping trips to seeing their grandparents, and I know they will be excited to hear there are more adventures coming at the end of the year.
This is where we take the chance to talk about what we have been playing and what's worked well for our families, from a newcomer and experienced perspective.
This week we talk about the following games:
We'll be back with more gaming surgery questions soon.
Andy Robertson appears in this podcast. "Videogame reviews for the whole family, not just the kids. I dig out videogame experiences to intrigue and interest grownups and children. This is post-hardcore gaming where accessibility, emotion and storytelling are as important as realism, explosions and bravado."
With so many different perspectives it can be hard to know where to start - a little like walking into a crowded pub. Sorry about that.
But so far we've not found a way to streamline our review output - there's basically too much of it. So, rather than dilute things for newcomers we have decided to live with the hubbub while helping new readers find the columnists they will enjoy.
Our columnists each focus on a particular perspective and fall into one of the following types of gamers: